# White hat vs black hat link building: the real risk of cheap PBN backlinks

> White hat link building vs cheap PBN backlink offers: Google's link spam policy, manual actions, disavow caveats and how to spot risky sellers.

Source: https://www.fyadvisers.com/blog/white-hat-vs-black-hat-link-building/  
Author: Fiona Wang, FYAdvisers  
Published: 2026-11-15  
Last updated: 2026-11-15

White hat link building means earning links that other websites choose to give you, and labelling any link you pay for as sponsored or nofollow. Black hat link building means buying or manufacturing links to manipulate rankings, for example the "buy PBN backlinks cheap" packages sold on marketplaces and in cold emails. Google's spam policies list buying links that pass ranking credit as link spam. The usual outcome is that the links are ignored, and the worst case is a manual action that pushes your pages down or out of Google's results.

This guide sets out what Google's documentation actually says, how manual actions and the disavow tool work, and how to spot a risky link offer before you pay for it.

## White hat vs black hat at a glance

| | White hat | Black hat |
|---|---|---|
| Where links come from | Real publications, partners, associations, directories people use | Private blog networks (PBNs), link farms, hacked or expired sites |
| Why the site links | Your page helps its readers | It was paid, or is controlled by the seller |
| Paid links | Marked `rel="sponsored"` or `rel="nofollow"` | Sold as "dofollow" to pass ranking credit |
| Anchor text | Mostly brand names and plain descriptions | Repeated exact-match keywords |
| Pace | Gradual, tied to content and campaigns | Hundreds of links in days |
| What you can verify | Every link, on a site with real traffic | Often a list you cannot audit |
| Risk under Google's policies | Low | Links ignored, or a manual action |

## What Google's link spam policy says

Google's [spam policies](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/essentials/spam-policies#link-spam) define link spam as creating links to or from a site primarily to manipulate search rankings. Examples Google lists include:

- Buying or selling links for ranking purposes, including paying money, or giving goods, services or free products in exchange for a link
- Excessive link exchanges, or partner pages created only for cross-linking
- Using automated programs or services to create links to your site
- Text ads or text links that do not block ranking credit
- Paid advertorials, native advertising, guest posts or press releases with links that pass ranking credit or use optimised anchor text
- Low-quality directory or bookmark site links
- Keyword-rich, hidden or low-quality links embedded in widgets, footers or templates across many sites
- Forum comments with optimised links in the post or signature
- Low-value content created mainly to manipulate linking and ranking signals

The same page makes an important distinction: Google accepts that buying and selling links is a normal part of advertising and sponsorship. Paid links are not a violation if they carry `rel="nofollow"` or `rel="sponsored"`. Google's [guidance on qualifying outbound links](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/crawling-indexing/qualify-outbound-links) says sponsored is the preferred value for paid links.

So the problem is not paying for exposure. It is paying for a link that pretends to be editorial.

### Where PBNs fit

A private blog network is a group of websites run by one seller, often built on expired domains, that exist mainly to link out to paying customers. Google's policy does not use the term "PBN", but a PBN link is a link bought for ranking purposes on content created mainly to manipulate linking signals, which matches several of the examples above.

## How Google responds to link spam

Google can act in two ways.

**Algorithmically.** Google's [ranking systems guide](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/ranking-systems-guide) describes spam detection systems, including SpamBrain, that are updated to keep up with new spam. When Google announced its [July 2021 link spam update](https://developers.google.com/search/blog/2021/07/link-tagging-and-link-spam-update), it said the update was designed to identify and nullify link spam more broadly. A nullified link simply stops counting, so you may have paid for nothing.

**Manually.** The [spam policies](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/essentials/spam-policies) say Google also uses human review, which can result in a manual action, and that sites violating the policies may rank lower or not appear in results at all.

## The Manual Actions report in Search Console

Google's help page on the [Manual Actions report](https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/9044175) explains how this works:

- A manual action is issued when a human reviewer decides pages on a site do not comply with Google's spam policies.
- You are told in the Manual Actions report and in the Search Console message centre. The report shows a green check mark if there is nothing to fix.
- Each action lists the affected pages or URL patterns, which can be part of a site or the whole site.

Two link-related actions are relevant here:

| Manual action | What Google detected | What Google asks you to do |
|---|---|---|
| Unnatural links to your site | A pattern of manipulative links pointing to you, such as bought links or link schemes | Download your links, identify the bad ones, ask site owners to remove them or add nofollow, disavow what you cannot remove, then request review |
| Unnatural links from your site | Paid or manipulative outbound links, such as excessive link exchanges | Remove the links or make them not pass ranking credit, for example with nofollow or sponsored, then request review |

Google says partial fixes do not restore visibility, so every listed issue must be fixed before you request a review. Your request should explain the issue, the steps you took and the outcome. Google says most reviews take several days or weeks, and some link-related ones take longer.

## The disavow tool: useful, but not a safety net

Black hat sellers sometimes tell buyers that any harm can be undone with a disavow file. Google's [disavow links help page](https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/2648487) is more cautious:

- It describes disavowing as an advanced feature that should be used with caution, and says incorrect use can harm your site's performance in Search.
- In most cases Google says it can work out which links to trust without extra help, so most sites do not need the tool.
- You should disavow only if you have a considerable number of spammy, artificial or low-quality links pointing to your site, **and** those links have caused, or are likely to cause, a manual action.
- Google asks you to try to remove the links from the linking sites first.
- After a successful upload, it can take a few weeks for Google to recrawl and process the list.
- The tool does not support Domain properties, and each property has a single list that is replaced each time you upload.

The Manual Actions help page adds that blindly disavowing all backlinks can cause a reconsideration request to be rejected, and that you should not disavow organic links. In short, disavowing is a clean-up step after a problem, not permission to buy links.

## How to spot a risky link offer

The offers look similar whether they arrive as a cold email, a marketplace gig or a line in an agency proposal. Warning signs:

- **"Dofollow guaranteed"** or "permanent dofollow links" on paid placements. Google requires paid links to be sponsored or nofollow.
- **Fixed counts at very low unit prices**, such as hundreds of links in a package, with no named sites.
- **Metric-led selling.** The seller quotes third-party authority scores but cannot show real readers or traffic on the linking sites.
- **Unrelated or generic sites.** Blogs that cover everything from casinos to health to home loans.
- **Expired domains rebuilt as blogs**, often with archive copies showing a completely different former owner.
- **Exact-match anchors on request**, such as "best aircon servicing Singapore", repeated on every placement.
- **No list of links**, or a report you cannot verify yourself.
- **Promises of rankings or fast results.** Google says there is no way to pay for a better local ranking in its [Business Profile help](https://support.google.com/business/answer/7091).
- **"Guest posts" or "press releases" with followed links bundled in.** Google lists these as link spam when the links pass ranking credit.

If you are comparing agencies, ask each one to describe where its links come from and to show a sample report with source pages. Our guide on [how to choose an SEO agency in Singapore](/blog/how-to-choose-seo-agency-singapore/) has more questions to ask.

### A Singapore note on sponsored content

Google's rules are not the only disclosure standard. The Advertising Standards Authority of Singapore's [Guidelines for Interactive Marketing Communication and Social Media](https://asas.org.sg/Portals/0/Guidelines%20for%20Interactive%20Marketing%20Communication%20and%20Social%20Media%20(web).pdf) say marketing communication must be identified as such and distinguished from editorial content, and that disclosures for sponsored content should be clear and prominent. The guidelines cover marketers including blog owners and agencies. A paid article dressed up as independent editorial can fall short on both fronts.

## If you have already bought links

1. Check the [Manual Actions report](https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/9044175) in Search Console.
2. Export your links from the [Links report](https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/9049606), and get the list of placements from the seller if you can.
3. Stop any ongoing link packages.
4. If there is a manual action, ask site owners to remove the links or add nofollow, disavow only what you cannot remove, then request a review.
5. If there is no manual action, read Google's disavow criteria before uploading anything. Google says most sites do not need it.
6. Put the budget into links you can keep. Our guide on [how to check backlinks](/blog/how-to-check-backlinks/) helps with the audit.

## How FYAdvisers builds links

FYAdvisers' [link building service](/services/link-building/) uses white hat methods only: linkable content, digital PR to relevant publications, partner and supplier pages, unlinked mentions, broken link recovery and listings people actually use. We do not use PBNs, link farms, automated tools or bulk directory submissions.

Every sponsored placement is marked `rel="sponsored"` and labelled as such in your monthly report, which lists each link with its source page, target page, anchor text and link type. If you are worried about links bought in the past, we can review your link profile first and tell you whether Google's documentation suggests any action is needed.

## Frequently asked questions

### What is white hat link building?

White hat link building means getting links in ways that follow Google's spam policies: earning editorial links with useful content, digital PR, partner and supplier relationships, and genuine directories, and marking any paid or sponsored link with rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow".

### What is the risk of buying cheap PBN backlinks?

The main risk is with Google. Its spam policies list buying links that pass ranking credit as link spam, and sites that break the policies can rank lower or be removed from results. Separately, paid content aimed at consumers on social media should be disclosed under ASAS guidelines.

### How do I know if my site has a manual action?

Open the Manual Actions report in Google Search Console. It shows a green check mark if there are none, or lists each action with the affected pages. Google also sends a message in the Search Console message centre.

### Should I disavow links a previous SEO agency bought?

Only in specific cases. Google says you should disavow only if you have a considerable number of spammy, artificial or low-quality links pointing to your site and they have caused, or are likely to cause, a manual action. Try to get them removed first. Google warns that incorrect use of the tool can harm your site.

### How long does a reconsideration request take?

Google says most reviews take several days or weeks, and some link-related requests can take longer. You get an email when the request is received and when the review is complete. Do not resubmit while a request is pending.
